Tuesday, 14 October 2025

Jacqueline Rose, Mothers

Reading this book made me feel like I should read it annually.

Some reference notes and a passage: 

  • Perfection and mother’s ambivalence - failure should not be seen as catastrophic but necessary and normal 
  • Winnicott and healthy hating 
  • Winnicott and the false self 
  • Mothers as scapegoat
  • Bettelheim and hating/blaming mothers for child’s destruction
  • Birth/labour akin to war
  • Clytemnestra pleading with her son Orestes to save her life by exposing her breast - an effort to remind him of their intimacy and her having fed and sustained him - which does not work and he kills her 
  • Cultural and psychoanalytic ignoring of the mother’s erotic pleasure breastfeeding her baby (and the few sources that do address it)
  • Erasure of mothers’ sexuality and the idealisation of mothers
  • How can/should a mother bear her daughter’s protests without shattering? How can mothers really hear and listen to their children? 
  • Hoping not that your child is happy but that they develop a rich, independent life
  • Elena Ferrante and mothers with blurred margins